By James Hamel
We spent a large portion of the last year road testing subcompact offerings from every single automaker all the way from Nissan down to Mitsubishi with the following three models standing head and shoulders above the rest. Yes, if you read the headline you would see that they are, in no particular no order, the 2015 Honda Fit, the 2015 Hyundai Accent and the 2015 Ford Fiesta with the impressive 1.0 3-cylinder Ecoboost motor. Too bad more of the car didn’t impress.
Do consider the incredible feat that this represents considering that none of the subcompact competition for these three exemplary small cars is really bad, unless of course you count the Nissan Versa sedan which is not only inferior to the Versa Note but to most used cars on the market as well. Slow, noisy, bare bones with all of the pleasant feel of a solitary confinement chamber in a third world gulag, we really don’t recommend the 2015 Nissan Versa sedan at all. Otherwise, models like the Toyota Yaris, Mitsubishi Mirage, Chevy Spark, Kia Rio and Chevy Sonic all are fine choices. They just aren’t the best.
Well, you already know who made the top three among the subcompacts we drove this year. But read on to find out who came out on top.
Unfortunately our Fiesta test unit was the sedan which we think is much frumpier looking than the sporty, euro-styled hatchback model. We suggest you go that route. Now, as far as styling goes Hyundai and Honda both took very different yet modern approaches. Admittedly, the 2015 Honda Fit looks the most like a robot from the future that merely has transformed into a roomy hatchback. One could imagine as it drives along that possibly it is humming along to “Domo Arigato Mr. Roboto” by Styx. But we do have overactive imaginations.
Our 2015 Hyundai Accent tester was a GLS sedan which proved to be the most mature and grown up looking vehicle in our trio. For a more European and somewhat sportier look Hyundai offers the Accent also as a five door hatchback this year even with a special Sport model which adds features as well as dresses up the exterior to at least make it look faster. No changes were made to the engine, the same 1.6 liter 137 horsepower/123 lb. feet of torque 4-cylinder found in our shapely sedan. So all in all, if you want post-modern future thinking go with the Fit whereas the Accent is perfect for those who want styling that won’t look dated in two years. (1st Place (Tie): 2015 Honda Fit EX and 2015 Hyundai Accent GLS, 3rd Place: 2015 Ford Focus Sedan 1.0 Ecoboost)
Interior Quality, Layout and Roominess
Both the Honda and Hyundai trump the Ford for that elusive “feel-good” factor as far as interior ambience goes simply because both the Accent and Fit use more soft touch plastics and upscale feeling materials than the Fiesta SE we tested. The Fiesta also had the most cramped back seat that also gave you the odd sensation you were sitting in a ditch. Otherwise trunk space was on a par with the Accent which admittedly had more comfortable seats all around and an airier feel to its cabin.
But seriously, no one can compete with the room, utility and interior comfort offered by the 2015 Honda Fit. Yes, you can still fold the rear seats and fit a Mountain Bike in there thanks to the return of the “Magic Seat.” It’s not magic, Honda just moved the gas tank to under the front seats thereby freeing up room. No matter how it was done, the 2015 Honda Fit offers up 52.7 cubic feet of cargo space when the seats are folded flat which is a figure that beats many small SUVs. Frankly, it’s bigger than some Manhattan apartments in there. (First: Honda Fit, 2nd: Hyundai Accent, Third: Ford Fiesta)
For the Rest of this Comparison Test Click here for a link to the entire article on my Honda and Acura Examiner page!